Raising Your Own Live Bait for Fishing: A Complete Guide

By Derrick R. Stallings – HuntingOfficer.com

If you’ve ever found yourself staring at the steep price tag of live bait at your local tackle shop and thought, “There has to be a better way,” you’re not alone. Many anglers—whether seasoned pros or casual weekend fishers—have begun raising their own bait. It’s a great way to save money, ensure a steady supply, and have a little more control over your fishing experience. But before you start building worm bins or setting up minnow tanks, it’s worth taking a deep dive into the what, how, and why of raising your own live bait.

What Kinds of Bait Can You Raise?

When it comes to raising bait at home, there’s more variety than most people expect. Some of the most popular and practical options include:

1. Worms (Nightcrawlers and Red Wigglers):
These are probably the easiest and most common live bait to raise. Worms are excellent for freshwater fishing and are loved by species like bass, bluegill, catfish, and trout. Nightcrawlers are larger and more robust, while red wigglers are smaller but reproduce quickly.

2. Crickets:
A go-to bait for panfish and trout, crickets are simple to breed in a container or plastic tub. They’re especially effective in warmer weather, and fish love their natural movement on the water.

3. Mealworms and Waxworms:
Often used for ice fishing or when targeting finicky biters, these are another easy insect to raise. They don’t take up much space and are relatively low-maintenance.

4. Minnows (Fathead Minnows, Rosy Reds):
Minnows are more advanced to raise but can be extremely rewarding. They’re perfect for targeting larger predators like bass, pike, and walleye. A small backyard pond or indoor tank can be used to raise them, though water quality and temperature must be monitored closely.

5. Crawfish (or Crawdads):
These crustaceans are like candy to bass and catfish. You can raise them in tanks or kiddie pools with a filtration system. They do require a bit more effort due to their aggressive nature and cannibalistic tendencies, but they’re worth it.

6. Black Soldier Fly Larvae:
An up-and-coming bait choice, these larvae are high in protein and can be fed on food scraps. Some anglers swear by them for catfish and carp.

---

How to Raise Each Type

Worms:
Start with a bin (plastic storage tote works fine), bedding made from shredded newspaper or coconut coir, and a moist (but not wet) environment. Keep them in a shaded spot, preferably in a garage or shed. Feed them vegetable scraps, coffee grounds, and crushed eggshells. They’ll breed over time, giving you a steady supply.

Crickets:
Use a plastic tub with ventilation holes. Add egg cartons for surface area and a small container with moist sand or peat moss for laying eggs. Feed them chicken feed, vegetables, and oatmeal. Keep the environment warm—around 80 to 90°F.

Mealworms:
These thrive in a plastic container filled with wheat bran or oats. Add slices of potato or apple for moisture. Adult beetles will lay eggs in the substrate, and within weeks, you’ll have a new batch of mealworms.

Minnows:
You’ll need a tank or pond with clean, oxygenated water and a filtration system. Fathead minnows are the easiest to breed. Feed them crushed fish flakes or live brine shrimp. Provide structure in the tank for hiding and spawning, like flat rocks or PVC pipes.

Crawfish:
Set up a tank with gravel, hiding places, and good filtration. Crawfish need clean water and are sensitive to ammonia buildup, so regular maintenance is key. Feed them sinking pellets, vegetables, and dead fish. Separate the young from adults if cannibalism becomes a problem.

---

Pros of Raising Your Own Bait

1. Cost Savings:
Over time, the cost of raising bait can be significantly lower than buying it each time you go fishing. Once your setup is established, you’re mostly investing time and a bit of maintenance.

2. Convenience:
You never have to worry about the bait shop being closed or out of stock. You’ve got live bait on hand, any time you feel the itch to hit the water.

3. Control Over Quality:
When you raise your own bait, you control what they’re fed, how healthy they are, and how they’re stored. That means fresher, livelier bait that’s more appealing to fish.

4. Sustainability:
Producing your own bait reduces reliance on commercial harvesting of wild bait populations. It’s a small step, but one that helps preserve aquatic ecosystems.

5. Educational and Fun:
If you have kids or simply enjoy tinkering and learning, raising bait can be a fascinating and rewarding side hobby. It teaches responsibility, biology, and even a bit of homesteading.

---

Cons of Raising Your Own Bait

1. Time and Effort:
While the daily care may not be too intensive, raising bait does take consistent attention. Neglect your worms or let your cricket habitat get too humid, and you might lose your stock.

2. Space Requirements:
Some setups are compact, but others—especially for minnows or crawfish—take up space and require specific environmental conditions.

3. Initial Costs:
While it’s cheaper over the long term, the initial setup (bins, tanks, filters, etc.) can cost more than a few trips to the bait shop.

4. Risk of Die-Off:
A sudden temperature swing, water contamination, or overfeeding can wipe out your whole bait colony. It happens. And when it does, you’ll either have to start over or make an emergency trip to buy more.

5. Not Always Practical:
If you only fish occasionally or don’t have the time to maintain a bait system, it may not make sense to raise your own. Sometimes, it really is easier to buy a dozen worms for a spontaneous trip.

---

Final Thoughts

Raising your own live bait is a rewarding way to get more in tune with the fishing lifestyle. It’s not just about saving a few bucks—it’s about creating a self-sustaining system that feeds into your love of the outdoors. Whether you’re breeding crickets in a spare room, tending to a worm farm under your workbench, or managing a backyard minnow pond, the process builds patience and provides a deeper connection to the hobby.

If you fish often and enjoy the DIY spirit, give it a shot. Start small—maybe with worms or mealworms—and see how it fits into your routine. Who knows? You might find yourself not only catching more fish, but gaining a whole new appreciation for the bait that gets you there.